Amateur Creampies review

Top Creampie Sites

Amateur Creampies

Initial Review: 2008-06-09

Last Update: 2009-07-22

Teen girls with cunts dripping with cum after a hard-fucking action is what this site is all about. Amateur as it may be considered, brings you a distinctive level of sexual gratification.


  • Quantity
    13.0 / 15
  • Quality
    12.0 / 15
  • Update Freq.
    7.0 / 10
  • Exclusivity
    10.0 / 10
  • Entertainment
    8.0 / 10
  • Downloadability
    5.0 / 5
  • Extras
    3.5 / 5

Cost / Markup

  • Value/Money
    15.0 / 20
  • Markup
    0.0 / 5


  • Navigation
    2.5 / 5
  • Design
    2.5 / 5

Final Score


Out of 100
  1. Amateur Creampies - 78.5

  2. 5-Guy Cream Pie - 77.5

  3. Creamed Cuties - 77.5

  4. Creampie Ebony - 76

  5. Internal Violations - 75.5

  6. Deep In Cream - 74.5

  7. Creampie Mania - 73.5

  8. Creampie Cuties - 73

  9. Dripping Cream Pies - 70

  10. Teen Pies - 69

  11. Creampied Sweeties - 68

  12. Asian Creamy Pies - 67.5

  13. Just Creampie - 66.5

  14. Homemade Creampies - 66

  15. Cream Filled Babes - 66

  16. Creampie Models - 64

  17. Dripping Goo - 64

  18. Black Creamy Pies - 64

  19. Creamy Pie Holes - 63.5

  20. Creampie Squad - 63

View all Creampie sites
View all Amateur sites
Picture Samples:

    Feed Button


  • 100% unique, exclusively shot content.
  • Good quality of photos paired on video.
  • Models are provided with info/story.
  • Lots of material to find here.
  • 10 other exclusive sites included upon membership (most of which are creampie related).
  • Two vid formats in WMV and MPEG, with WMV being multi-bandwidth.
  • Must check out episodes: "Nikki Anne", "Reena Sky", "Chayse Evans" or "Misty Love" to name a few.
  • Well-sized collection.
  • Pretty good, amateur feel.


  • Photos and videos are not available on all models.
  • Site design is dated.
  • Would be nice to add more extra content.

Bottom Line

  • Amateur Creampies is well done for the most part. The creampie action itself is well shot and highly entertaining. They also took care of the video problem, which was that in the past their videos screen resolution was so low. The massive quality improvements now make AmateurCreampies a valid option if you are into amateur creampie action, especially because most of the additional bonus sites are also in the creampie niche.

The Facts



Secondary Categor(ies):

Amateur, Hardcore, Videos


Details: Weekly updates.

Join Options:

Credit Card, Check


$29.95 (1 Month, Recurring)
$59.95 (3-Months, Recurring)


No DRM license restrictions.


434 photo sets (avg. 100 pictures)
Hi-Res: Y | Different Sizes: Y | ZIP Files: Y | Slideshow: Y
Image Resolutions: 1200x800 (Hi Res), 800x600 and 800x533 (Standard)

contentCALC [?]:

As of today, 2019-04-24, there should be 944 photo sets available

contentCALC accuracy:

for this site is currently not available (too soon to verify accuracy).


349 video set (avg. 20 minutes)
Downloadable: Y | Streams: Y | One-File Downloads: Y | Multi-Bandwidth: Y | Vid Caps: N
Average movie size: 95MB (1-File WMV), 70MB (1-File RM)

contentCALC [?]:

As of today, 2019-04-24, there should be 861 video sets available

contentCALC accuracy:

for this site is currently not available (too soon to verify accuracy).

Video Format(s):

WMV High: 640x480, 1.29 Mbps
WMV Medium: 320x240, 793 Kbps
WMV Low: 160x120, 254 Kbps
Flash: 640x480, bitrate unknown
Real Media: 320x240, 312 kbps

More Content Details:

Condoms used in scenes: No
Download Limit: There is a daily download limit of 5GB.
Download Speed: 430 KB/s (reviewers max: 527 KB/s / 4219 kbps).
Content Exclusivity: Content appears to be all exclusive.
Model Index: No

10 out of 25 available features shown.

Video Review is N/AShow / Hide the Members Area Screenshot Launch the Gallery Console

with your membership:

This Amateur Creampies review is based on the facts / status when written /updated on 2008-06-23:

The Site
Amateur Creampie is a site started by Rick, the guy who started other amateur sites like Girls Climaxing and Nextdoor Amateur. This time it's all about stuffing horny amateur girls with the white baby batter.


- 100% unique, exclusively shot content. Rick really goes out his way to find beautiful girls. He travels a lot just to fuck women and feature them for the first time on this site. I sure envy this Rick dude, you know.
- Good quality of photos paired on video. With the videos are photo sets in 1200x800 (Hi Res) quality and 800x600 and 800x533 (Standard) quality.
- Models are provided with info/story. In the model page you'll see the picture of the model, some info about the model, and a little background or story about how, where, and when Rick met the model; and a little bit of what happened the day they met. Free Access To Other Sites. 8 other exclusive sites included upon membership (most of which are creampie related). Sites included with the membership are: West Coast Gangbangs, Hot Wives and Girlfriends, Creampie Ebony, DP Amateurs, Creampie X, Elizabeth del Mar, Facial Site (soon to be relaunched), Yahoo Club, and Creampie Pics. Well-sized collection. The number of their content as of this review is commendable. This site already has 353 photo sets with an average number of 100 pictures per set. There are around 107 video sets available in its library videos you can download anytime you want to.


- Some Models Lack Video or Photo Content. There are some models that don't have picture or video content. This might disappoint some members for most of the members expect the content to be complete. Site design is out-dated. The site, I believe, needs to have a makeover. It looks pretty simple to me when it can be better.
- Video resolution is too low (only 320x240). It's disappointing to see really low resolution videos. Yes, it is amateur. But it doesn't mean that you can not provide the output in a higher quality. This is 2008.
- Would be nice to add more extra content. Amateur Creampies has a decent number of content, but it would be a lot better if it has more content that members can enjoy. Beefing up the site's picture and video content would be a wise decision for the people behind this site.

Amateur Creampie is a nicely done site. It's got very entertaining content. My concern is that it really needs an aesthetic change and the video quality needs to be enhanced pronto. It really doesn't deserve the quality it is currently presented in. Other than that, I'd say it's a site that deserves to be checked out, including its other sister sites that go with the membership.

Quick Tour Preview

Review Log:

2009-07-22: Quick Facts updated, contentCALC activated.
2008-06-28: Amateur Creampies review added.
2008-06-18: added to database, Quick Facts added, Sample Amateur Creampies galleries added.
  1. Hot Wives and Girlfriends - 77

  2. West Coast Gangbangs - 76

  3. Creampie Ebony - 76

  4. Girls Climaxing - 76

  5. Creampie Squad - 63

  6. Double Penetration Amateurs - 48.5

Visitor Ratings:

Votes: 3

Average Rating: 100.0 / 100